Home> Blog> Ultimate Comparison: Heat Pump Water Heater vs Electric

Ultimate Comparison: Heat Pump Water Heater vs Electric



The choice of a water heater for your home is a very difficult one as far as the selection between a heat pump water heater and an electric water heater is concerned. Both options have their own peculiar advantages and limitations, and the knowledge of these is prerequisite for an informed choice. This article will explore the heat pump water heater vs electric water heater issue so that we can see the energy efficiency, cost, performance and environmental impact. At the conclusion of this article, you will have all the details needed to make your choice based on the needs of your household and budget.

Understanding Heat Pump Water Heaters

Heat pump water heaters, also known as hybrid water heaters, are an innovative and energy-saving measure that can serve your home hot water needs. This type of heat pump takes the warmth from the surrounding air and puts it into the water in the storage tank. This process is carried out by using a compressor, evaporator, and condenser that function in a way similar to household refrigerators and air conditioners.

One of the major benefits of heat pump water heaters is the fact that they offer very high energy efficiency. Through the application of the laws of heat transfer, the units can generate hot water with a much low energy usage compared to a traditional electric water heater. Indeed, a heat pump water heater can be as high as three times more energy efficient than a standard electric water heater, and this implies that the energy cost is considerably cut.

Residential water heater with the front pane

Delving into Electric Storage Water Heaters

The electricity storage water heater is the most common kind of water heater found in the homes all over the United States. The storage units have a water tank that stores a specific amount of water usually between 20 to 80 gallons and they are insulated. The water is warmed by one or two electric resistance elements that are placed inside the tank by a thermostat.

However, the capital cost of electric storage water heater is generally lower than that of heat pump water heater vs electric options, but these devices are less energy efficient, thus, they have a higher operating costs. The energy factor (EF) of the standard electric water heater is usually between 0.90-0.95, which implies that 90-95% of the energy goes into heating the water, with 5-10% of the energy being wasted as standby heat.

Exploring Electric Tankless Water Heaters

Tankless electric water heaters, also known as instant water heaters, can deliver hot water on demand and do not require a storage tank. These units are heated by the flowing water (through an electric heating element) which is very powerful. Whenever a hot water tap is turned on, fresh water flows through the unit and is quickly heated and delivered to the point of use.

In addition to the fact that the electric tankless water heaters are relatively small in size, they are also suitable for households with space constraints. They are also a big source of standby energy loss as tank units, but they only heat water when it’s needed. On the other hand, electric tankless water heaters may have installation costs that are higher and may need home’s electrical system upgrade to support their high power requirement.

Tankless hot water heater

Comparative Analysis of Heat Pump Water Heater vs Electric Ones

Energy Efficiency Comparison

When the heat pump water heater is contrasted with the electric storage and tankless water heaters, the heat pump water heaters become the obvious choice. The energy factor of up to 3.5 makes heat pump water heaters one of the most efficient devices for water heating and thus reduces energy consumption and water heating costs. The EF of electric storage water heaters ranges from 0.90 to 0.95, whereas the EF for electric tankless units is about 0.98, which makes them more efficient than electric storage units, but still less efficient than heat pump models.

Cost Comparison

In terms of the upfront expenditures, both the heat pump and tankless electric water heaters are more expensive than the traditional storage tank electric water heaters. On the other hand, the energy savings potential of heat pump water heaters for the long run is very high as they are much more efficient than traditional systems. In contrast, a heat pump water heater is up to 3 times more energy-efficient than a conventional electric water heater, and it results in saving around 300 dollars per year on utility bills for an average household. In other words, even though the bigger upfront cost exists, the heat pump water heater can be recovered in a short time due to the reduced energy usage.

Performance Comparison

Heat pump water heaters are slower to reheat the water temperature in the tank compared to conventional storage water heaters so you need to take this key difference into account when choosing between these two types of new water heaters. In contrast, electric water heaters with storage tanks will ensure a continuous supply of hot water since they keep the temperature of the water in the tank. Tankless electric water heaters are instant hot water providers but can pose flow rate issues, especially when water is used by various appliances and fixtures concurrently due to limited air space. The homeowners of the house must very thoughtfully evaluate their household’s hot water demand and usage pattern as they weigh the performance differences between the various water heater options.

Environmental Impact Comparison

When it comes to the environmental benefits, the heat pump option is unquestionably superior to electric heat. Through the reduction in energy use, heat pump water heaters are instrumental in lowering greenhouse gas emissions and producing a comparatively lower carbon footprint. Electric storage and tankless water heaters, although not as environmentally friendly as heat pump models, still have a lesser environmental impact when compared to the gas water heaters.

FeatureHeat Pump Water HeaterElectric Storage Water HeaterElectric Tankless Water Heater
Energy Efficiency (Energy Factor)Up to 3.50.90 to 0.95Around 0.98
Upfront CostHigherLowerHigher
Long-term Energy Cost SavingsHighestLowestModerate
Reheating SpeedSlowerFasterInstant
Hot Water SupplyContinuous (with tank)Continuous (with tank)On-demand
Space RequirementsDedicated space for tankDedicated space for tankCompact, wall-mounted
Climate DependencyAffected by ambient temperaturesNot affectedNot affected
Environmental ImpactLowestModerateModerate
thermostat of electric water heater

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Water Heater

Household Size and Hot Water Demand

The size of your household and your daily hot water demand are crucial factors to consider when selecting a water heater. For larger families or homes with high hot water needs, a heat pump water heater or a larger electric storage unit may be more suitable. Electric tankless water heaters can be an excellent choice for smaller households or homes with limited hot water requirements.

Budget and Energy Costs

The budget and energy costs must be taken into the account and both the initial and the potential long-term energy cost savings have to be evaluated for each water heater option. Contrary to the fact that new heat pump water heaters have a higher initial purchase price they pay for themselves through heat pump technology and their energy efficiency, which can result in substantial cost savings over time. Homeowners should also check on the available rebates and government subsidies and grants for buying energy-saving appliances, for instance, the federal tax credit for heat pump water heaters, which may help to reduce the initial investment and make these environmentally friendly options more attractive from the financial perspective.

Available Space and Installation Requirements

The available space in your home and the installation requirements for each water heater type should also be considered. Heat pump water heaters and electric storage units require a dedicated space for their storage tanks, while electric tankless water heaters have a compact design that can be mounted on a wall. However, electric tankless units may require electrical system upgrades to support their high power demands.

Climate and Ambient Temperatures

The climate and ambient temperatures in your area can impact the performance and efficiency of heat pump water heaters. These units rely on extracting heat from the surrounding air, so they may not perform as effectively in colder climates or in areas with consistently low ambient temperatures. In such cases, an electric storage or tankless water heater may be a more suitable choice.

Heat pump water heater from jnod

Making an Informed Decision: Heat Pump vs Electric

While choosing between a heat pump water heater and an electric option, it is important to weigh your household’s specific needs, budget, and ecological choices properly. When you are looking for the energy efficiency and long term cost savings, a heat pump water heater will be the best option for you. Nevertheless, if the upfront costs and installation simplicity are giving more weight, then an electric storage water heater would be the best option. For those who are endowed with limited space and instant hot water need, an electric tankless unit could be the best choice.

Basically, you will be able to make a right choice that will fit your home and family after having an insight of the specific attributes, advantages, and disadvantages of each water heater type. It does not matter which model you select among the heat pump water heaters, the electric storage systems or the electric tankless types. All of these models will give you a reliable and steady supply of hot water while contributing to an ecologically sustainable future.

Recent Blog